Questions and Answers on Tme Series Modeling


Questions and Answers on Tme Series Modeling

Author
Message
JoeyR
Junior Member
Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 11, Visits: 1

Should I be trying to replicate the NEAS results?

[NEAS: This is an independent student project. The NEAS postings are suggestions to get you started. You can construct an ARIMA model, compare two or more models for a given era, compare two or three eras by type of model of by model parameters, examine seasonality, test out-of-sample forecasts, and many other items.]


Reply
n2thornl
Junior Member
Junior Member (19 reputation)Junior Member (19 reputation)Junior Member (19 reputation)Junior Member (19 reputation)Junior Member (19 reputation)Junior Member (19 reputation)Junior Member (19 reputation)Junior Member (19 reputation)Junior Member (19 reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 20, Visits: 1

CM-

Thank you.  I had forgotten that those equations were in there.  I think I will try that, if it comes to it.

So, what made you want to try an AR(2) model?  Did your AR(1) model just not fit right? 

Did you check forecasts against actual data to decide which model was better, or what?

Just curious... you don't need to reply if you're busy.

Thanks again!

Jacob: How do we compare an AR(1) model with an AR(2) model? If the AR(2) model has a higher R2 and a lower sum of squared residuals, won’t its forecasts also be better?

Rachel: The AR(2) model will have the higher R2 and the lower sum of squared residuals. This must be the case, since the AR(2) model uses the same independent variables as the AR(1) model plus an additional variable. But its out-of-sample forecasts may be worse. For a perfect random walk, this will often be the case.


 
GO
Merge Selected
Merge into selected topic...



Merge into merge target...



Merge into a specific topic ID...




Threaded View

Threaded View
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
jnissley - 19 Years Ago
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
jnissley - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
SaulGood - 19 Years Ago
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
root4unc - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
PayMeBack - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
JulieC - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
kquick - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
kquick - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
PayMeBack - 19 Years Ago
kquick - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
actually ..? - 18 Years Ago
Help! - 17 Years Ago
seattleact - 17 Years Ago
Alan - 15 Years Ago
Alan - 15 Years Ago
Alan - 15 Years Ago
Alan - 15 Years Ago
Alan - 15 Years Ago
ker8 - 15 Years Ago
bermyluv - 14 Years Ago


Reading This Topic

1 active, 1 guest, 0 members, 0 anonymous
No members currently viewing this topic!

Login
Existing Account
Email Address:


Password:


Login
Social Logins

  • Login with twitter
  • Login with twitter
Select a Forum....













































































































































































































































Neas-Seminars