Questions and Answers on Tme Series Modeling


Questions and Answers on Tme Series Modeling

Author
Message
JoeyR
Junior Member
Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)Junior Member (11 reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 11, Visits: 1

Should I be trying to replicate the NEAS results?

[NEAS: This is an independent student project. The NEAS postings are suggestions to get you started. You can construct an ARIMA model, compare two or more models for a given era, compare two or three eras by type of model of by model parameters, examine seasonality, test out-of-sample forecasts, and many other items.]


Reply
kquick
Forum Newbie
Forum Newbie (4 reputation)Forum Newbie (4 reputation)Forum Newbie (4 reputation)Forum Newbie (4 reputation)Forum Newbie (4 reputation)Forum Newbie (4 reputation)Forum Newbie (4 reputation)Forum Newbie (4 reputation)Forum Newbie (4 reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 4, Visits: 1

I am with you, I get the theory of this stuff but when it comes to application, I get a little fuzzy.

I used as my e^t = actual (delta)yt - predicted (delta)yt, for the first differenced equation.  Basically it is actual minus predicted.  I had a little trouble calculating e^(t-1) which we need for the MA component of the model.  In other words, I need to calculate this in order to get the predicted (delta)yt.  What I did was use e^(t-1) = actual (delta)yt-1 - mean.  I used the calculated mean of my model.  This was just to get the intial value of e^(t-1).  Then for all subsequant values, I used actual minus predicted (delta)yt-1 values.

I hope this makes sense.  I am really looking for someone to give me an idea of what they did for this.  For people whose models have an MA component, how did you calculate the e^(t-1) value to get your predicted values.

Jacob: How do we get the estimated values for an autoregressive model?

Rachel: Suppose the order of the autoregressive process is p. For an AR(1) model, p = 1; for an AR(2) model, p = 2.

For t > 2, yt is estimated from the ARIMA model.

For t = 2, we assume y0 = the mean of the ARIMA model.

For t = 1, we assume y0 and y–1 = the mean of the ARIMA model.

Jacob: If the ARIMA model has a moving average component, how do we determine the estimated values?

The estimate for y1 requires knowledge of ε0, which we don’t know.

The estimate for yt requires knowledge of εt-1, which we don’t know, since we don’t know the estimated value of yt-1.

Unless we have a way of starting, we don’t know the estimates for any values.

Rachel: We assume the residuals for all values before the first observed value are zero.

Jacob: The candidate who posted this message used the actual minus the mean as the residual. Is this wrong?

Rachel: This is not wrong; we don’t know the true residual for the first period. This candidate’s method is as good as any, though the textbook uses the method described above.


 
GO
Merge Selected
Merge into selected topic...



Merge into merge target...



Merge into a specific topic ID...




Threaded View

Threaded View
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
jnissley - 19 Years Ago
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
jnissley - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
SaulGood - 19 Years Ago
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
root4unc - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
PayMeBack - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
NewTubaBoy - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
JoeyR - 19 Years Ago
JulieC - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
kquick - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
kquick - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
Chesters Mom - 19 Years Ago
PayMeBack - 19 Years Ago
kquick - 19 Years Ago
n2thornl - 19 Years Ago
actually ..? - 18 Years Ago
Help! - 17 Years Ago
seattleact - 17 Years Ago
Alan - 15 Years Ago
Alan - 15 Years Ago
Alan - 15 Years Ago
Alan - 15 Years Ago
Alan - 15 Years Ago
ker8 - 15 Years Ago
bermyluv - 14 Years Ago


Reading This Topic

1 active, 1 guest, 0 members, 0 anonymous
No members currently viewing this topic!

Login
Existing Account
Email Address:


Password:


Login
Social Logins

  • Login with twitter
  • Login with twitter
Select a Forum....













































































































































































































































Neas-Seminars